Nanette, Owen Benjamin and How the Death of Comedy Sucks

When Hannah Gadsby announced that she quit comedy, all the media world-wide fawned. How wonderful. She was about to go around with a trite program, “Nanette,” and expected to play it a handful of times before frying chips at a McDonald’s for the rest of her life. What she could not expect was the wave of support and the international interest in her retirement. She got a Netflix special, well-paid gigs and finally she had to admit that the revived interest makes it impossible for her to follow through. The money is more important than accusations of hypocrisy.

What happened? It used to be a joke that people would make street music with the sign that says, “I stop singing for a dime.” But this joke is real and big. A comedian quits and people are so happy about it that she becomes a star over it.

Who wants comedians to quit? Comedy harms the powerful first and foremost. There is a level of irreverence and uncontrollable honesty that ships with the art. So the celebration of an end of comedy is natural for the news media. I read not only one, but TWO articles about her in my German newspaper ZEIT. But there are also certain personalities who have an interest in taking down comedy.

Totalitarianism is the revenge of the stupid.

Imagine you have spent all your life nervously trying to figure out when others start laughing so that you don’t do it at the wrong time. It must be very stressful. Many people claim that it is impossible to detect satire on the internet. We see a flood of emoticons because some people really, really cannot figure out if you are serious or not. Better be safe than sorry. But why is it that some people understand jokes and others don’t?

A joke reveals something, contains a little riddle, gives cues, and relies on the listener to figure it out. Imagine you happen to overlook contradictions regularly. Imagine you could be told sentences like “The private individual must abide to the constitution” and would not notice the obvious contradiction between “abide to constitution” and a person who does not represent any part of the state. How easy would your life be if we did no longer laugh? How much less embarrassing would it be if people did never hint, but alway had to spell out unambiguously what they have in mind? If it’s not hostile and they are well-behaved, there should be no reason for jokes, should there?

One of the articles about Hannah Gadsby in my newspaper was written by Hannah Passmann. ZEIT is trying to build her up as a kind of house star like Milo when he was with Breitbart. They also made a podcast with her and without listening much into it, I can quickly tell that she is not funny. Even Michelle Wolf, Sarah Silverman and Amy Schumer are funnier than her. Passman called Gadsby the best comedian of all times. We are hitting the bottom.

Some cartoon shows are still on the air, but for how long? After the destruction of the  high-rating sitcom Roseanne, it is reasonable to assume that the anti-humor juggernaut will soon roll over all the fun that is left. By the way, I want to apologize to apes if they feel compared to Valerie Jarret. I am racist enough to consider apes lower than humans, but not lower than Jarret and the mob that went after Roseanne in her name. It takes the lowest spirit to see a mob in one’s name and not to stop it. That message also goes to German soccer player Jérôme Boateng.

Still there is something that the entertainment industry calls comedy. They are shows and events where laughs from the audience are somewhat common. They are not heard because some insight was had, but because the authority of a blinking ‘applause’ sign sets people into a frenzy.

And Owen Benjamin? We wouldn’t even hear about him if it were not for the death of humor. He has turned his profession into activism against the humorlessness. The problem is that he is not funny. Comedians who are and who have an audience to lose when they speak up fear the end of their professional lives as the mobs keep roaming around.


3 thoughts on “Nanette, Owen Benjamin and How the Death of Comedy Sucks”

  1. Prager is a special kind of stupid. Look at this discussion with Shermer and Rubin, where he thinks he can drown out everyone with his booming loud voice, effectively ignoring every argument.


    1. I was lucky to catch the moment when Prager does what you say, somewhere around 22:00. Would have been easier if you told me cause its a long video. But thanks anyway.

      I like Prager and he is usually smart. It makes no sense to prove G-d, but I find it equally absurd to disprove him.

      Still, I have decided to show our cultural roots again and I have scheduled theological posts for Saturdays. I believe that people hold their noses and support Björn Höcke because he is a history teacher and talks about some German roots from time to time. There is a longing.

      We have lost our common assumptions as Owen Benjamin rightly says in the PragerU video. More specifically we have lost a shared moral system. Is it good to have elections? I’m sure you can whip up the frenzy on the left to the point where they say, “Hitler was elected.” This is because the shared common knowledge is very thin, very very thin. And so is the moral ground that follows from a shortage of cultural knowledge. I had a post on the Battle of the Thirty to also slip in some European history. The article ended with a biblical story that resembled the event. The glimmer of Christianity is still the most promising foundation on which one can base some common references with which moral guidelines can be discussed. The anti-American racism makes a direct reference to the founding fathers less palatable to many people. But that is another road to go and I appreciate people who do talk about them.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.